Another Debate on Hudud – Nasrudin vs Karpal?
KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 – PAS Youth Chief, Nasrudin Hassan today still retain facts regarding Karpal Singh’s readiness to compromise implementing hudud law even if it is refuted by the Chairman of the DAP.
Not only that, but Nasrudin also defended the fact that PAS is the dominant party in the Opposition.
As such, he challenged any of the debates organized another two points if they claim that when the debate put forward by the Chairman of the Executive Committee of Young Scholars Malaysia (Science), Josh Jahaya last Thursday as a lie.
” Both of these facts I expressed in the debate. Should it was a lie then it must be countered in the debate. If they were not happy, arrange another open debate and invite us.” he said.
Earlier, DAP chairman Karpal Singh expressed extreme displeasure upon learning that Pas Youth chief Nasrudin Hassan Tantawi had suggested that he had been willing to consider such laws for the country during a political debate.
“I will never compromise,” said Karpal.
-----------------------------------------------------
Karpal slams Pas Youth head’s hudud comment
KUALA LUMPUR: DAP and its ally, Pas, appeared yet to reach an understanding on the possibility of implementing hudud if they ever come to power.
Yesterday, DAP chairman Karpal Singh expressed extreme displeasure upon learning that Pas Youth chief Nasrudin Hassan Tantawi had suggested that he had been willing to consider such laws for the country during a political debate.
“I will never compromise,” said Karpal in a telephone interview with the New Straits Times.
“I have always been very public and absolute on my stand to never have hudud implemented in the country… how then can he (Nasrudin) claim such a thing?” said the DAP stalwart, who is well known for his strong opposition to any attempt to introduce Islamic laws in this country.
Hudud is a term used to describe the class of punishments for certain crimes such as theft, fornication and adultery, consumption of alcohol or other intoxicants and apostasy.
“The decision not to have hudud is not only my strong decision but also the stand of the DAP as a whole.”
Karpal said the issue was also not open to any form of “negotiations” in the form of discussions.
“We need to keep the best interests of the people in mind. I will never ever budge or compromise on my stand… not on the idea to implement hudud, especially.”
Nasrudin had uttered the offending remark during a debate with Umno Working Committee Secretariat of Young Ulama chairman Fathul Bari Mat Jahaya.
The debate on Thursday, titled “PRU13: Orang Muda Pilih Siapa”, was organised by the tabloid, Sinar Harian.
The excerpts of Nasrudin’s remark from the debate read as follows: “I would like to ask my friend Fathul Bari to update me about Karpal Singh… he (Fathul) said Karpal Singh had said, “…over my dead body” when the idea to implement hudud came about 10 years ago…
However, like Fathul said, it was 10 years ago. Now, after a recent Pakatan Rakyat convention in Penang, Karpal said after he had befriended Pas, the issue of hudud can be discussed again. This means that there is some sort of understanding (between Pas and DAP) about the law. I am not surprised if a non-Muslim does not accept hudud but it is shocking when Muslims detest it.”
The video clip of the debate can be viewed at MobTV.my, an Internet TV portal. The portal covers various issues, including business, politics, lifestyle, religion and entertainment.
Nasrudin, in a text message to NST’s query on whether he had made such a remark about Karpal’s stand on hudud, said “Tak ada” (I did not).- NST
No comments:
Post a Comment